N.B. this blog series is a short version of a publication in the special edition on “Next Steps for Digital Currencies” of the Journal of Payments Strategy & Systems, JPSS, Henry Stewart Publications, March 2023.
Please contact the publisher or the author for a reprint
Introduction
This blog will come in three parts. In this, the first part, we will quickly review what CBDC is, who is driving this development, what central banks are trying to solve and what the current state of play is. In the second blog we will discuss some of the concerns that have been raised – whether the goals are achievable at all, what the concerns of other stakeholders in the ecosystem (such as banks, merchants, end customers) are and why there is a real danger that this whole development may be a big global “flop”. In the final blog we look at the advantages to all – not just the central banks who are driving this development – and why it may be worth all of us working together to make this new money a reality.
What is CBDC (Central Bank Digital Currency)
This paper will not enter into a detailed discussion of what constitutes a central bank digital currency (CBDC) as numerous excellent introductions are available elsewhere. For the purposes here, it is sufficient to quote Masaki Bessho, Head of the Bank of Japan’s FinTech Center, and say that CBDC provides ‘wide access to public money in the post-cash world’ (simply put: electronic versions of coins and banknotes). At the moment only banks have access to central bank money (cash and deposits) and then distribute these to end-consumers and businesses. The idea behind CBDC is that everybody – not only banks – can access public (i.e. central bank) money. However, this does not mean that the man in the street can open an account at the Turkish Central bank – instead, CBDC will still be distributed via commercial banks like Isbank, Akbank, etc. So for starters, one can immediately question what is really new here and what problem CBDC is trying to solve !? Why do we need “electronic versions” of coins and banknotes at all since we already move our money around electronically very well !? How does one explain to the normal person that he will have some “Garanti Lira” in his bank account/wallet/app but also some “TCMB Lira” !? The “CBDC money” will be limited (e.g. to 3000€ per person to avoid a digital bank run), whereas the “normal money” can be held in unlimited amounts. CBDCs will likely offer no interest, whereas money on normal savings accounts return normal interest rates. The normal money has always been assured to be safe (and often guaranteed to 100.000€) – but now suddenly this new money is supposed to be even safer (being backed by the state) ? That all makes no sense to anybody.
However more than 100 central banks around the world (representing 95% of global GDP) are busy working on CBDC, some have even already rolled it out – notably China who already started with a task force almost 10 years ago. The Turkish Central Bank has also started publicly thinking about this[1].
So what are all these Central Banks trying to achieve given the already raised fundamental questions ?

Motivations for central banks, governments and policy makers
By a considerable margin, it is the central banks themselves that stand to benefit most from the introduction of CBDC. Some of the ideas proposed could be very real, but many of the commonly cited advantages go up in smoke upon closer inspection:
- We do not need CBDC for digitisation nor for innovation. We already have massive use of electronic funds (in some countries the use of paper cash for payments has almost disappeared) and payments is one of the global business areas with the most innovation of all.
- Some governments want to increase inclusion with CBDC (however they will need to solve the topic of eIdentity first)
- Some want to reduce the cost of cash distribution – this makes a lot of sense given the enormous costs associated with the distribution of paper notes and metal coins[2]. However, the use of cash for payments is already in steep decline in most economies, even without CBDC.
- Some (who do not care too much about privacy) want to trace their populations’ spending, or – more positively – want to get more and better data about their populations’ spending habits so that interest rates can be set more immediately and based on better real live economic data
- Some regulators see an opportunity in CBDC as giving legitmacy to banning crypto, such as was voiced by Fed Chairman Jerome Powell: “One of the arguments that are offered in favor of a digital currency, in particular, you wouldn’t need stablecoins, you wouldn’t need cryptocurrencies if you had a digital US currency.”
- Some want to increase the payment infrastructure’s resilience and efficiency (e.g. by creating an offline variant of CBDC that can be used without electric power and without computer networks). This is particularly important in areas where there may be natural disasters and conflicts.
- Some hope to distribute helicopter money quicker and more directly to the population and to small businesses. The government subsidies need to reach those who need it most rapidly in times of crises, pandemics, conflicts (and not get stuck in the intermediate banks). However the currently envisaged 2-tier system, will again mean that intermediaries are in between the central bank and the users wallets.
- Some want more efficient, cheaper, faster, more transparent cross-border payments (using a non-retail version of CBDC in the wholesale/inter-bank domain). This has the potential to also improve the 794bn$ remittance market. However, for that the 100 central banks across the world will need to agree on a common/interoperable way of implementing CBDC.
- Some want to introduce coloured money (sometimes called tagged money) to control use of money: Beneficiaries of social payments can spend the benefit support on food and clothing but the money will not ‘work’ at the off-licence or casino. Parents can use CBDC to preload a smartcard with pocket money for their children, which they can then use anywhere (even offline, without Wi-Fi, without a smartphone), at the same time limiting the number of energy drinks and sweets they can buy.
- Some want to reduce fragmentation (a strange goal, since we are adding yet another payment means, thus surely increasing fragmentation)
- Some want to add new levers to monetary policy (e.g. if one can eliminates cash, one can enforce negative interest rates. In Japan, where there are negative interest rates, i.e. the money depreciates as it sits in a bank account, people currently “escape to cash”: they take their savings out of the bank and instead put bundles of notes in a safe or under their mattress. But if cash is abolished there is no escape. Not a problem for Turkey at the moment, but something for everyone to keep an eye on.)
- Finally, one of the most frequent reasons cited is to increase sovereignty and retain the monetary anchor. This last goal is likely driven by the shock caused to the financial system by Facebook’s attempt to introduce Libra as a new global digital currency. However, Libra has since failed and future threats to fiat money by Crypto are surely best combatted by regulation (such as Europe’s MiCa, Turkey’s regulation of 30th April 2021, etc) not by introducing another state currency.
In summary, there is a wide catalogue of more than a dozen reasons – not all of them very convincing – why central banks are currently planning to introduce CBDC. Some indeed speak of “Central Bank FOMO” – that each central bank is only doing it because the other central banks are doing it, and don’t want to miss out.
But assuming that we do want to achieve some of the benefits of CBDC, it is not enough just for the central banks to think this is a good idea. For CBDC to become a success, all stakeholders need to engage. It must also be of benefit to citizens, consumers, businesses, corporates, retailers, merchants, commercial banks and others in the payment ecosystem. Otherwise there just will not be any adoption.
With this in mind, the next blog will look at the wider stakeholder ecosystem to see what the opportunities and concerns of the other actors beyond the central banks might be.
[1] https://fintechistanbul.org/2022/09/28/tcmb-baskani-sahap-kavcioglu-cbdc-kullanim-olanaklari-uzerinde-calisilmasinin-onemine-degindi/
[2] For example:
- in the major 13 European countries, the ancillary costs associated with the provision of cash are approximately €22bn per year;
- in Japan, the cost of maintaining the ATMs alone is ¥700bn per year;
- in USA, the Fed pays approximately US$800m per year to print new currency;
- the UK, the Royal Mint levies a fee of 12 per cent to print cash (eg £60m to make £500m);
- in the Bahamas — an archipelago of 700 islands, where hurricanes are frequent — cash distribution is particularly fraught;
- in Sweden, the outer reaches of which are also hard to reach, cash use is rapidly tending to zero, so that any remaining bank notes and coins have very poor unit costs.
If cash could instead be distributed electronically – the idea behind CBDC – these costs could be massively reduced.
Michael Salmony
salmony@fintechistanbul.org


