I. Introduction

The Global Conference on Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs) was convened 12-14th September 2023 in the magnificent city of Istanbul, following the equally excellently organised event in Frankfurt of the year before.
This text aims to capture the personal essence of the conference.

With participation from over 40 central banks worldwide, 63 speakers from industry practitioners, academics, and service providers, the conference enjoyed a diverse and influential audience of over 200.

II. Central Banks no longer the centre of the universe – a widening view

In contrast to the previous conference, where central banks primarily focused on their own individual interests and the policy goals they could achieve with CBDCs, this year witnessed a shift in mindset. The ecosystem (see VIII.) is beginning to come into focus.

III. Last year: CBDC is to solve very many things

Last year the urgency of issuing CBDCs as a response to challenges like Libra, US Bigtech dominance (developed economies) and financial inclusion, reducing cost of cash distribution (emerging markets) drove the discussions. Indeed 32 different policy goals for CBDC have been posited around the globe:

Fig 1: Central Banks trying to achieve (too) many things with CBDC. (Research/source: author)

IV. This year: a more focussed view

This year, however, many central banks focused heavily on CBDC as an alternative source of central bank money when cash disappears. (Meanwhile, of course, cash and CBDC are to coexist).
Amongst the developed economies, the ECB still names 5 policy goals for CBDC and acknowledges that others have at least 5 more <source: Jurgen Spaanderman, De Nederlandsche Bank, citing ECB> but the narrowing of focus from huge diversity of policy goals to far less was one of the dominant take-aways.

V. Is physical cash really disappearing?

Despite an almost universal decrease in cash usage for payments in many regions, physical cash „in circulation“ continues to grow massively. This is for hoarding and illicit activities where cash is the medium of choice. In only a few global niches, such as the Nordics, there is a real decline in cash.

Fig 2: Cash is growing massively (almost) everywhere. (Source: Prof. Peter Bofinger, University of Würzburg)

This puts in question if/when the new CBDC focus as “a substitute when cash disappears” is relevant.

VI. A 20-year horizon ?

Another important change of view from last year to this, was that central banks no longer seem to be in such a hurry. Last year, the urgent threats (digitisation, social media money, crypto, Bigtech, …) seemed to require a rapid response. This year many central banks spoke of a 20-year timeline for CBDC implementation. This may may align better with the new focus on replacement in the post-cash era, and will give everyone more time to think the very complex topic through in all its dimensions (see below). However, given the lightning speed of payment innovations, where in 20 years we may see avatar-based transactions authenticated in an AR-universe by pay-by-blink, the idea of a new form of “cash” or “banknotes” may then be rather risible.

VII. The complex ecosystem of payments

However, it was very welcome to see that central banks are now willing to take their time and get it right. The multifaceted nature of payment systems, where everything, from objectives and business models to user interfaces and governance, etc must be got right, needs time.
Failure in even one critical aspect will lead to the failure of the entire system, as seen in many past payment initiatives.

VIII. The imperative of ecosystem thinking

The importance of considering the broader ecosystem, beyond just the central banks, is thus becoming increasingly clear. This ecosystem comprises commercial banks (see XI.), retail and corporate customers, governments, service providers, merchants, and more. The motivations and incentives of all these stakeholders must align for the system to succeed and good adoption to be achieved.

IX. I What is „good“ adoption ? The Goldilocks Zone

The adoption of CBDCs must strike a delicate balance, neither too low to have wasted all our time and effort, nor too high as this will destroy the banking system – as one participant succinctly put it.

X. Cross-Border

A recurring topic was whether CBDC can improve cross-border payments (which are famously intransparent, expensive, slow and put burdens on migrant workers and inhibit global trade). All agreed that both retail and wholesale CBDCs could play a role in improving this situation but a number of questions were raised: Will CBDC designs around the world align sufficiently for there to be efficient interoperability ? Why will CBDCs fare better than existing cross-border fiat solutions ? Will other private and public initiatives (G20, Swift Go, Wise, PayPal, …) to improve cross border overtake any CBDC initiatives ?
It will be interesting to hear the answers in future.

XI. How to engage commercial banks?

One of the most urgent challenges is engaging commercial banks, who are currently very wary of CBDCs and hardly present at the event. Their involvement is critical, as they are expected to perform several functions without direct compensation.

Fig 3: Commercial banks are being asked to do very many tasks – for free. (Source: Prof. Peter Bofinger, University of Würzburg, citing ECB)

Also CBDC hits them where it hurts the most: if too much money flows into CBDCs, commercial banks will suffer massive liquidity loss, impacting their lending capacity, which is of course the core of banking.
Given the high costs, no returns, negative impact on their core business model – how can one possibly motivate commercial banks to play their critical distribution role ? No-one seems to have an answer, let alone thought seriously about this.

The ecosystem clearly needs much more work.

XII. Offline CBDCs

An intriguing sub-aspect explored at the conference <see IDEMIA> was the potential of offline CBDCs, especially through secure elements in smartphones (developed economies) or chip cards. These latter have the potential to improve privacy, simplify access, enhance inclusion and provide resilience, particularly in regions with limited access to technology (or even electricity) and can be life-saving in remote areas, after earthquakes or other natural disasters.
However, one must first understand why all ePurses (Geldkarte, Chipknip, Proton, etc) have all failed[1], whose operating principles are not a million miles from the proposed offline CBDC,

XIII. CBDC is not a technical topic

One thing one can hope is at last becoming increasingly clear. In the past, the 20 sponsors of the event had captured the agenda, suggesting that all one needs is a Blockchain, a DLT, a token, “smart” “contracts” (which are neither smart nor contracts, as was pointed out), or whatever their preferred IT solution is.

Fig 4: Technology companies trying to capture the agenda.s (Source: conference)

However, it is surely clear CBDC is not a technical topic.

Instead of coming from the bottom up, a top-down approach is necessary:
a) first define policy goals first (what – of the 32 reasons – is one really trying to achieve? What problem is one trying to solve? Is CBDC the best tool to solve this problem?). The answer(s) may be different according to region, development and wider government strategy.
b) then the many design options to achieve the goal(s) have to be clarified (what is the distribution model, what is the governance, what will be the commercial model for all parties, will there be a scheme, motivations to all players, right level of privacy, dispute resolution principles and many more)
c) once one has a clear understanding of all of the the above, then one can begin to ask, not bankers, but some qualified system architects (who have no particular agenda, are not locked into the thinking of a specific provider or technology) to devise an appropriate technical architecture that has the necessary characteristics (performant, scalable, flexible, future-proof, hardened by years of experience) which may well end up being an account-based, distributed database.

Let us be open about the implementation and not start with the technology.

XIV. Concluding Remarks

In summary, the Global Conference on CBDCs in Istanbul offered valuable insights into the evolving thinking of central banks. The emphasis on finding the right goal, right time horizon, meticulous planning, ecosystem thinking, and the challenges of engaging all critical players (esp. commercial banks) were central themes.
As the conference ended, one thing became abundantly clear – CBDCs are not just about technology but also require a profound understanding of policy, design, and the complex dynamics of payments ecosystems.

Many well-meaning, well-intentioned, well-informed, well-funded initiatives have failed in the past.

Contact us to profit from decades of experience around the world in successfully launching new complex payment systems.

Fig 5: Chairing panels on CBDC Ecosystem and CBDC Cross-Border Payments
with Banque de France, World Economic Forum WEF, Central Bank of Israel, Ripple,
International Monetary Fund IMF, Central Bank of Zambia, Banco Central del Uruguay

See you at the cbdc-conference.com  in 2024 !

Author: Michael Salmony, 20th September 2023

[1] Leo Van Hove’s multiple publications on the subject e.g. “Electronic purses: (which) way to go?”, First Monday, Vol. 5, Nr. 7, July 2000, https://firstmonday.org/ojs/index.php/fm/article/view/770/679 saying “initial expectations about consumer uptake and retailer acceptance of e-purses were unrealistic … the initial euphoria has faded away … Today, things look even bleaker”

For example, the German pre-paid card “Geldkarte” was introduced 1996 and closed 2024, never having achieved any significant adoption (0.1%) despite huge investments in cards, terminals, communication etc over many years, https://www.spiegel.de/netzwelt/tech/geldkarte-von-den-kaeufern-verschmaeht-a-60536.html

Michael Salmony
Dr Michael Salmony is an internationally recognised leader on strategy of business innovations in digital and financial services with a particular focus on Payments, Open Finance, FinTech, Digital Identity, e-Invoicing/SCF and Electronic Money/CBDC. He has particularly close links with Turkey, being strategic partner to FinTech Istanbul (on all matters Open Finance, Platforms, FinTech, APIs, BaaS, Neo-Banking, and further digital financial services), as lecturer on digital finance at the Ozyegin University Graduate School of Business Istanbul, as frequent keynote speaker at several digital finance events in Turkey, as correspondent with various banks, specialist lawyers, relevant corporates etc in Turkey. Globally, he is board-level advisor to major international banks, industry associations, regulators and finance bodies across the world and regularly helps shape future directions in all key decision making bodies (e.g. European Commission/ECB/European Parliament in Europe, and central banks from Japan to Uruguay and Kazakhstan). For the last 10 years he has served as Executive Adviser to the Board of Worldline Financial Services, helping to bring them from a local player to become the world’s 4th largest financial processor of transactional services, which handles over 17 trillion Euro per year. He also works with multiple geographic regions where Digital Finance Innovations are currently emerging - for example with the World Bank in Central Asia, as Board Member of Fintech Africa, as Advisory Board Member to Mastercard in Latin America, etc. His views are much in demand as keynote speaker at international events and he appears on TV/Radio/all electronic media on advances in finance and is quoted extensively (e.g. Financial Times, Harvard Business Manager, New Scientist, The Economist and governments from Ghana to Malaysia). He lectures i.a. at the Oxford Business School on "AI in Fintech and Open Banking" and has published much own original work which has been translated into many languages including German, Italian, Dutch, Finnish, Polish, Danish, Turkish, Russian, Chinese and Japanese. He is extensively networked into the new financial services space and has the top 5% most viewed profile out of the 600 million members in the world’s largest professional network LinkedIn. Previous positions include Director Business Development of leading national central bank (Bank of the Year, Best Innovator Award). Before entering the world of finance, he helped transform companies and business models in many industries as IBM's Director of Market Development Media and Communications Technologies. He studied at the University of Cambridge UK and is married, with two millennial children.